Skip to main

Best Sandwiches in Williston

Freshly Made Sandwiches, Ready When You Are!

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Gabe's Favorite Sub

Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pickles, Mayo

Add Item

Italian Panini

Ham, Salami, Provolone, Onions, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, Pickles, Vinegar, Oregano

Add Item

The Bob Panini

Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar, Ranch

Add Item

Turkey Panini

Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar, and Pesto Mayo

Add Item

Toasted BLT Sandwich

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Mayo

Add Item

Buffalo Chicken Melt Wrap

Marinated Buffalo Chicken, Cheddar, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Ranch (served hot)

Add Item

Pacific Beach Wrap

Roasted Chicken, Fresh Guacamole, Cheddar, Lettuce, Olives, Chipotle Mayo

Add Item

Welcome to Yellow Mustard🥪

Welcome to Yellow Mustard🥪
Looking for a fresh, satisfying meal that won’t slow you down? Yellow Mustard is here for you! With convenient locations in downtown Montpelier, Williston, and Burlington, we serve up handcrafted sandwiches, hot soups, and fresh-baked cookies daily. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, ordering takeout for home, or planning catering for an event, we’ve got you covered. Stop by today and treat yourself to a delicious meal that’s made fresh just for you!

Fresh Ingredients, Real Flavor

Fresh Ingredients, Real Flavor
Every sandwich at Yellow Mustard starts with high-quality ingredients. Our team prepares everything fresh each day, making sure every bite is packed with goodness. Try our Italian Grinder for a classic favorite, order Gabe's Favorite for something special, or dig into The Bob for a sandwich that keeps our customers coming back. No matter what you choose, you’ll get bold flavors and quality ingredients in every order.
See Full Menu
Quick and Convenient Ordering

Quick and Convenient Ordering

We know life gets busy, and good food should be easy to get. That’s why we offer both delivery and pickup options. Whether you're on a lunch break, working from home, or planning a picnic by the lake, ordering from Yellow Mustard is simple. Place your order online or stop by one of our locations in Burlington, Williston, or Montpelier—we’ll have your food ready fast.
Order Now

Fresh, Simple, and Always Made to Order!

A look inside our kitchen—fresh ingredients, perfectly made sandwiches, and cookies that just came out of the oven. Every order is prepared fresh daily, so you get great food every time.

Let Us Handle Your Catering

Let Us Handle Your Catering
Got a meeting, party, or special event? Let Yellow Mustard handle the food! Our catering service brings fresh sandwiches and more straight to you. Whether it’s for a small office lunch or a big celebration, we make it easy. Call us today: 📞 Montpelier: 802-225-6131 📞 Burlington: 802-540-1349 📞 Williston: 802-764-0826 Or fill out our catering form to get started!

Come By and See Us!

Yellow Mustard is here to bring fresh flavors and fast service to Burlington, Williston, & Montpelier. Visit us at - 170 St Paul St, Burlington, VT - 28 State St, Montpelier, VT - 27 Taft Corners, Williston, VT Stop in today, or order online for an easy and delicious meal. We’ll have it ready when you are!
Find Us in Burlington & Montpelier!

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

I'm glad I took a detour and found this place! The Hotel California sandwich is very good, and I recently tried the French Dip as well—not sure which I want to get next time!

Evan C.

Evan C.

The veggie panini was amazing! Good environment, and lunch was so yummy. Definitely will come back.

Eliza S.

Eliza S.

Stopped in for lunch today. The place is well lit and clean, but a little small. The staff was very helpful. The turkey panini was delicious.

Mike F.

Mike F.

Featuring

Delivery

Takeout

Catering

Dine In

Vegetarian Options

Get Rewards Every Time You Order!

Get Rewards Every Time You Order!

Love our sandwiches? Join our rewards program and earn points on every order. Redeem them for discounts, free food, and exclusive perks. The more you visit, the more you get! Signing up is easy—start earning today!

Frequently asked questions

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Our locations